Why Does Having A Higher Deductible Lower Your Insurance Premium?

Why Does Having A Higher Deductible Lower Your Insurance Premium?

The amount you will have to pay out of pocket before your insurance pays out is called your deductible. Homeowners insurance deductibles can be expressed as a percentage of your total coverage or as a dollar amount, while auto insurance deductibles are usually expressed as a $500 amount. You can choose a percentage or a dollar amount in some cases. There may also be distinct deductibles for various risks such as hail, wind, and hurricanes, covered by home insurance.

Why Does Having A Higher Deductible Lower Your Insurance Premium

There is a deductible per claim for homeowners, car, and renters insurance. Annual deductibles are a feature of most health insurance plans, but they work in a slightly different way. The amount you must pay for health care services in a given year—not including insurance premiums—before your insurance begins to cover the costs is known as your annual deductible. It is possible that certain medical services, like preventive care, will be covered without a deductible.

If, for instance, your annual health insurance deductible is $1,500. Until you reach your deductible, you pay for health care out of pocket. By then, your health care coverage dominates and pays your costs through the end of your insurance year. Your deductible is reset each time your coverage is renewed.

If you want, you can raise or lower your auto, homeowners, or renter’s insurance deductible. In most cases, there are minimum deductible limits.

You are unable to alter the plan’s deductible when you purchase health insurance or choose a plan through your employer.

On the other hand, you might be able to select between two distinct health insurance plans—one with a low deductible and one with a high deductible. High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) are defined by IRS regulations. HDHPs will have a maximum out-of-pocket cost of $7,500 for self-only policies and $15,000 for family policies in 2023, with a minimum deductible of $1,500 for self-only policies and $3,000 for family policies.


The Relationship between your Deductible and Premium

In most cases, the relationship between your deductible and premium is inverse. If you choose a lower deductible, your premiums will be higher, but when you file a claim, you will have to pay less out of pocket.

On the other hand, a higher deductible prompts lower insurance payments. You pay more personal when you record a case. Because there are fewer potential claims, the insurance company offers lower premiums.

A $10,000 claim with a $500 deductible, for instance, could result in a payout of $9,500 from the insurer. The maximum amount they would pay is $9,000 if you raise your deductible to $1,000.

When your deductible is higher, there is a potential of having to pay out of pocket when you make a claim. The insurance company charges lower premium because you have reduced their risk by undertaking it yourself.

READ: How Much Is Renters Insurance For A One Bedroom Apartment?

How Deductibles Affect You

There is a significant difference between deductibles of $500 and $5,000.

Certain individuals would prefer to have a more modest premium, and pay more direct for care as they go. Since you never know when you might end up with a lot of medical bills, it can make your costs harder to predict.

Certain individuals like having a real sense of safety financially. They like the fact that when they need insurance, they will not have to pay a lot of money before their plan starts paying for it. So they would prefer have a higher premium, however a lower deductible. It makes your expenses easier to predict.


Excessive Deductible: Advantages and disadvantages

While you are thinking about an insurance policy with a high deductible, know about the upsides and downsides.


  • Lower insurance premiums are the result of a higher deductible. This could mean the difference between getting essential insurance and not having any at all, depending on your financial situation.
  • A higher deductible might make sense if you do not intend to file claims for minor losses.


  • You will need to pay more personally when you record a case than if you had a lower deductible.
  • If you cannot afford to pay your deductible right away, car repairs may take longer.
  • Because your deductible is so high, if you have health insurance, you might be tempted to delay or skip necessary medical treatment.


Deductible is low:

A lower deductible has both advantages and disadvantages.


  • When you file a claim with your insurance, you will pay less than if you had a higher deductible.
  • If your deductible is low enough to be affordable, you will not have to wait to get your car fixed.


  • A lower deductible results in higher premiums because, in the event that you file a claim, your insurer is responsible for a larger portion of the costs.
  • You might be tempted to file insurance claims for relatively minor damages because you know you will not have to pay much out of pocket. Your premiums may rise as a result of filing claims which could wipe out any savings from the lower deductible.


How to Select the Best Insurance Deductible and Policy for You

Choosing the best insurance deductible is risky. If you never file an insurance claim, the savings from higher deductibles are certain. However, a high deductible could drain your bank account if you do submit a claim. While settling on your choice, consider:

  • How frequently you anticipate filing a claim. For example, if you live in a flood-prone area, you might want to lower your flood insurance deductible. However, if you cannot afford flood insurance with a low deductible, a higher deductible might make coverage more affordable and insure your home.
  • If you are able to cover a high deductible with your own money. You can cover your expenses before you reach a high deductible with a solid emergency fund.

The most effective way to pick either low or high deductible insurance is to analyze insurance policy. To get an idea of how much coverage you can afford, make a budget. Get estimates from a few different insurance companies for the same amount and type of coverage. After that, change the deductibles to see how it affects your premiums.

Raising your deductible is not the only way to cut insurance costs. A wide range of insurance discounts are usually offered by car insurance companies, such as when you keep a clean driving record, or pay your annual premium upfront. By installing burglar alarms and other safety features or updating your home’s systems, you may be eligible for discounts on your home insurance.

Your credit-based insurance score which is based on the same information as your regular credit score, can be checked by insurance companies in many states. Maintaining good credit and paying off debt may result in lower insurance premiums.

READ: Permanent Whole Life Insurance Quotes

Deductibles in insurance policies help insurance companies and policyholders share costs when they file claims. However, there are two different justifications for why organizations use deductibles. They are:

Moral Dangers

The possibility that a policyholder will not act in good faith is a moral hazard. Since insurance policies shield policyholders from financial losses, there is an inherent moral hazard: The insured party might participate in dangerous way of behaving without experiencing the financial consequences.

For instance, if drivers have vehicle insurance, they might have the motivator to drive in a foolish way or leave their vehicle unattended in a hazardous region since they are insured against harm and burglary. They have no stake in the outcome as there is no deductible.

Because the policyholder bears some of the costs, a deductible reduces that risk. Deductibles, in effect, aim to align the insurer’s and the insured’s interests in order to lessen the likelihood of a catastrophic loss.


Financial Stability

By lowering the severity of claims, deductibles in insurance policies guarantee the insurer some degree of financial stability. A well-structured insurance policy safeguards against catastrophic loss. A deductible acts as a buffer between a relatively minor loss and a truly devastating one.

Assuming an insurance policy did not have a deductible, the expense of each and every minor case, no matter what the sum, would be the guarantor’s liability. This would result in an overwhelming number of claims and raise the policy’s financial costs. Additionally, it may make it challenging for the insurer to appropriately respond to actual catastrophic losses sustained by policyholders.



Discover more from LoveyBlog - Lovey Insurance Blog

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Scroll to Top